What to do When NJ High Earners Don’t Qualify for 529 State Tax Deductions

NJ residents making more than $200k are excluded from one of the primary benefits of contributing to New Jersey’s 529 Plan.

Tax benefits are the primary reason many investors open 529 plans to save for education expenses. These mainly come in the form of:

  • Deferred taxes on the dividends, distributions, and growth of investments within the plan
  • Tax deductions from contributions made to the plan

The availability of, and rules for tax deductions from contributions vary significantly by your state of residence. We’ll be taking a look at the rules of a high-earner in New Jersey for this discussion.

NJ High Earners Are Not Eligible for 529 State Tax Deductions

In New Jersey, up to $10,000 a year of 529 Plan contributions are deductible from state taxes for residents contributing to the New Jersey 529 Plan. However, this deduction is only available for those with a gross income of $200,000 or less.

That means if you’re a New Jersey resident who is fortunate enough to earn more than $200,000 a year, you do not get the benefit of the state tax deduction for contributions made to a New Jersey 529 plan (though you still get the benefits of deferred taxes on the growth of your investments within the plan).

Look into other 529 plans if you don’t qualify for NJ State Tax Benefits

Compare your options vs. other plans.

Not all 529 plans are created equal when it comes to fees and investment options. And you are generally not restricted to just using your state’s 529 Plan.

Let’s take a look at the potential fee benefits a high-earning New Jersey household could realize by moving their NJ 529 plan to another state’s plan such as California.

For this comparison we are looking at:

  • 529 Plan State: the state where the plan is sponsored
  • Program Fees: asset-based fees charged by the plan administrator for managing the plan’s underlying investments
  • 60/40 Fees: fund fees for implementing a 60% Stock / 40% Bond portfolio utilizing the options available within the plan. Fees for each individual fund are noted in parentheses
  • Yearly Fees Per $100,000: the expected yearly program and fund fees paid for every $100,000 invested in the plan
529 Plan StateProgram Fees60/40 FeesYrly Fees Per $100,000
New Jersey0.10%10.046% blended
– Franklin U.S. Large Cap Index 529 Portfolio (0.03%)
– Franklin U.S. Core Bond ETF 529 Portfolio (0.07%)
$146
(0.146% total fees)
California0.01%20.058% blended
– Index U.S. Equity Portfolio (0.05%)
– Index Bond Portfolio (0.07%)
$68
(0.068% total fees)

Data as of September 16, 2025 from each 529 Plan Sponsor’s Website
1. No fee for Franklin U.S. Government Money 529 Portfolio
2. For passive and index investment options

For every $100,000 invested in New Jersey’s 529 Plan, you could be paying $78 more per year in fees vs. investing in a similar strategy within California’s 529 Plan.

This may seem small but this could add up to thousands of dollars over the life of your 529 plan when you consider that you are paying this every year per and losing out on the power of compounding each time you pay the difference.

If you found this post helpful:

Disclosures:
This content is for educational purposes only and is not an investment recommendation. This is an illustrative example highlighting the difference in program and fund fees between two 529 Plans allocated to 60/40 strategies using available options. There are other considerations when selecting a 529 plan such as availability of investments, the expected performance of those investments, and other fees. The selection of California in this example is arbitrary and is not an endorsement of any specific plan. Speak with a licensed financial advisor before making any changes to your investments. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Investing involves risk including the loss of capital.

Twice-monthly letters on the financial and emotional tradeoffs that come with mid-career success. No paywalls.

X

Twice-monthly letters on the financial and emotional tradeoffs that come with mid-career success. No paywalls.

X

Discover more from Kangpan & Co.

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading